Wednesday, January 12, 2005

Desperadoes

IT HAS always been an anomaly of the South African theatrical release schedule that local audiences are plied with serious “adult” films during the summer holidays when most people prefer a diet of special effects, action and laughs. At the movies “Coming this Summer! The Blockbuster Event of the Year!” usually means June.

It’s a southern hemisphere thing. Like supposedly proudly SAfrican retailers forcing shop assistants to wear beards and woolly outfits at 30 degrees Celsius or beach umbrellas being advertised by a cartoon reindeer slipping on ice.

This time of the year is also when Hollywood studios prefer to release likely Academy Award contenders so that they still linger in the mind of audiences and judges at the time of the big night (27 February).Closer – the new film by Mike Nichols, who must still be trading on the success of his 1966 film Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? that starred Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor rather than his middling recent efforts, including the aptly titled What Planet Are You From? – is definitely more suited to frosty mornings and ice-cold late nights.

Set in London, captured in all its dreariness, Closer features Jude Law, Natalie Portman (better known for her role as Star Wars’ senator Padme Amidala), Julia Roberts and Clive Owen (last year’s King Arthur) in a love rectangle of deception, betrayal, suspicion and jealousy.

Law is an obituary writer (his profession adds little to the script, aside from a few mildly entertaining jokes) who falls desperately in love with Portman, a stripper. However clichéd a choice, her job adds some spice and colour to an otherwise grey and depressing film.

Closer opens with their chance encounter: Portman steps in front of a taxi because, being from New York, she looks in the wrong direction at an intersection. Law rushes to her aid and the wait at the emergency room is long enough for them to fall desperately in love. So far into Closer you could almost have been watching a romantic comedy in the vein of Notting Hill or Pretty Woman.

Don’t be lulled into a false sense of security – the characters sure aren’t. Flash forward a year or so and, as is the wont of modern lovers according to Closer, Law falls desperately in love with Roberts the first time they meet.

Roberts is an American photographer (her career allows the film to say a few things about reality versus appearance) and is everything the young Portman isn’t – confident, sullen and tall.

Enter Owen, a dermatologist, who falls desperately in love with Roberts when they first meet. Roberts and Owen’s first encounter is also a parody of the romantic comedy – it happens to be her birthday and he even buys her a helium balloon as they stroll along the street. Owen is also everything Law isn’t – successful, funny and tall.

As the old joke goes, dermatologists are the wealthiest doctors because their patients never die but never fully recover either. So with these relationships. Every time the story jumps forward a couple of months or years the foursome have found new ways of tormenting each other and themselves. If the start of the relationships are parodied their dissolution comes close to being absurd. Not since Braveheart have so many grown men cried on screen.

Portman gives a performance that lives down her Star Wars turn. Anyone who witnessed the love scenes between her and Skywalker (it had lines like: “I don’t like the sand. It’s coarse and rough and irritating – not like you.”) will know that this says a lot.

But Roberts’s performance is so uncharacteristically contained and detached that it renders her character lifeless. Law is sufficiently craven and wheedling in Closer to blow away his sexiest man alive image; and Owen’s portrayal of the needy, manipulative and only skin-deep doctor is flawless.

But despite the good performances it’s difficult to feel much sympathy for the characters and with all the emotional intensity whipped up, without a connection to their world of hurt Closer soon seems pretentious and ultimately exhausting viewing.

There’s another film re-released in time for the Oscars that deals with many of the same issues. If you see only one film about what brings people together and what tears them apart make it Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, with Jim Carrey and Kate Winslet. The only thing pretentious about this movie is its title.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home