I don’t like Live8
THERE are few things quite so galling as political grandstanding by pop stars. Worse still, pop has-beens. Bob Geldof, organiser of the Live8 concerts, hasn’t made any music in years: his only real hit – I Don’t Like Mondays – was released in 1979.
However, his minor talents as a social commentator didn’t stop him from getting top billing on BBC World with his documentary Geldof in Africa, part of the BBC’s Africa Lives series. Interesting choice of title. Audiences in the developed world probably needed some reassurance that Africa is alive after being plied with images of dying and diseased Africans on giant screens everywhere in the rich world.
Geldof in Africa began with a pseudo-anthropological explanation of Africa’s relative backwardness. According to Geldof, Africa simply has too many dangerous animals and it’s too hot. He eventually ran out of metaphors for how hot it is here, saying: “It’s so hot here it’s like walking on the surface of the sun.”
Geldof should do a follow up for the BBC at Sun City and stay over at the Pilanesberg nature reserve. Maybe he’d be able to think straight if he were able to view the dangerous animals from an air-conditioned Land Rover.
Geldof wasn’t the only one to crawl out of the woodwork for good works. Pink Floyd played together for Live8 for the first time in 24 years. In Berlin, lady in red Chris de Burgh could rehash some of his moments, the Pet Shop Boys did Moscow, Paris saw Yannick Noah bang drums instead of tennis balls, Canada had Deep Purple come out of their depths and Snoop Dogg in his usual style told the Hyde Park crowd to “wave your motherfuckin’ hands in the air like you just don’t motherfuckin’ care”.
And don’t forget Elton John, who had this to say at the Live8 press launch on the BBC: “We have so much ignorance that we’re fighting. . . we have the President of South Africa saying that Aids is caused by poverty. I wish!”
I’m not one to defend Mbeki’s stance regarding Aids, but the “I wish!” is a bit rich coming from someone who spends £293 000 on fresh flowers in a year. (This information is from court papers after John sued his manager for millions in royalties.)
Of all the Live8 acts, Pink Floyd’s record sales jumped the most – up 13-fold from the week before. Sensing that they’d be accused of profiting from the misery of others, billionaire guitarist Dave Gilmour told Britain’s Telegraph: “If other artists feel like donating their extra royalties to charity, perhaps record companies could be persuaded to make a similar gesture and that would be a bonus.”
Notice the words “feel like”, “extra”, “perhaps”, “could be” and “bonus”: Live8 sure stirred the passions of the rich to fight poverty and end injustice. I always thought that Comfortably Numb was Pink Floyd’s best number, but only now do I understand its meaning.
Not only did Live8 hijack Nelson Mandela’s 46664 project – which has much the same aims and a much better follow-through – but Africa was also cut out of the action from the start. Instead of showcasing the talent of “a country like Africa” (to quote one G8 leader) and promoting trade and tourism, all the old clichés about the continent were reinforced. A small gesture like manufacturing the Live8 T-shirts and memorabilia selling so briskly on eBay in Africa would have shown that the organisers have some understanding of what it takes to end famine. Fat chance.
Even having African performers at the concert was too much to ask. The official Live8’s sister organisation – The Global Call to Action Against Poverty – can be found on www.whiteband.org. In the words of another fading pop star, Alanis Morissette: “Isn’t it Ironic?” Only after asking, and at the last minute, did Johannesburg become part of Live8. Still, Mandela – recently returned from the 46664 event in the Arctic Circle – had the magnanimity to come out in the dead of Johannesburg’s winter to lend his support. One hopes Live8 at least asked before they referenced the title of his autobiography in their slogan.
Instead of celebrating African talents you had the spectacle of Madonna dragging an embarrassed survivor of 1984’s Ethiopian famine around the stage. Of course, Madonna won’t play in Africa (won’t get the $400 she charges for a ticket here). Mariah Carey, for whose flagging career Live8 couldn’t have come sooner, a couple of years ago gave a glimpse into this mindset when she told an interviewer: “Whenever I watch TV and see those poor starving kids, I can’t help but cry. I mean, I’d love to be skinny like that but not with all those flies and death and stuff.”
The most telling example of the international pop world’s real relationship with Africa was at the concert in Philadelphia. There a new punk band from Britain hoping to make it big seized the opportunity to reach an audience of millions. Their name? Kaiser Chiefs. “It was a great honour to be involved in such a huge global event; hopefully it will have the desired effect” reads the band’s website. It already has, mate – whiteband sales are up. Way up.


0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home