Wednesday, June 18, 2003

You are not happy to see me

So that must be a gun in your pocket

IT IS rare enough to see a documentary on cinema screens in South Africa, much less a modestly hyped one. Michael Moore’s Bowling for Columbine (the title refers to the 1999 Columbine High School shooting in which two teenagers killed a dozen classmates after visiting a ten-pin bowling alley) comes with a new level of pre-release publicity for those who worry from a suitable distance about trends in society.

After Moore was booed off stage at the Oscars, Bowling for Columbine has received an award from just about every movie-judging panel ever convened outside North America. You get the distinct impression that if there’s only one person out of 250m patriots who worries enough about violence in and by Americans to make a doccie, then the rest of the world needs him to stay as close to the action as possible.

The film opens in a high-street bank where you get a shotgun with every account you open. You get it there and then, almost no questions asked on the application form – except whether you’re Caucasian. From here, Bowling for Columbine’s contributors just get funnier and scarier.

There is a seemingly dead-ordinary teenager who feels disappointed about only making number two on the list of the Columbine area’s Most Likely to Bomb and a freed Timothy McVeigh accomplice (McVeigh killed over 150 people in a terrorist attack the US originally blamed on Saddam Hussein) who manages to conflate loathing for his ex-wife and nuclear non-proliferation in a single sentence.

Bowling for Columbine works best when it tries to get at the reasons for ordinary Americans’ thing for guns, but when Moore tries to extrapolate what he finds chatting to people in pool halls and outside fast food outlets, to NATO action and American military intervention around the world, the film falls short.

The most compelling but ultimately depressing section late in the film is when shock-rocker Marilyn Manson (who, along with the South Park TV cartoon series and video games, was widely blamed in the US for the massacre) is asked what he’d like to tell the survivors at Columbine High School.

“I won’t tell them anything, I’d just listen. No one’s ever asked those kids what they think,” he answers. Manson’s pellucid suggestion, amid all the fudging by the pro- and anti-gun interviewees, does indeed rock the house. But in the next scene Moore talks to two classmates of the killers and the only nugget about their life and loves he’s able to extract is that taking bowling lessons might improve your bowling.

The finale of Bowling for Columbine is an interview with Charlton Heston as head of the National Rifle Association, a powerful political lobby group in the US, before he was forced to retire because of Alzheimer’s disease. Heston, with movie posters of his heyday as romantic leading man and biblical action hero in full view, dithers through Moore’s questioning and eventually lumbers out of his tennis-house with Moore shouting after him. Intended to show up the bankruptcy of the NRA and the views of right-wingers like Heston, the scene fails. All you see is a browbeaten old man for whom you can only feel pity. Unless you’re an American, I guess.

Much later that night, when worries about the possible impact of Dubya’s blanket warnings against general threats began to subside, I had a quick but unhappy meal at one of the growing number of US establishments in South Africa. I realised that I hadn’t mentioned the lessons of Bowling for Columbine for this country. But there’s nothing you can tell people around here about guns.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home