And in the red corner
THE Butcher Shop & Grill on Nelson Mandela Square in Sandton City is an institution. You can’t say you’ve had a Johannesburg business lunch until you have had one at Butchershop.
Since 1996, Butchershop has been where the corporate finance cowboys and the performance-bonus supertraders have gone to worship their god. In the Eighties, these guys were called Masters of the Universe, in the Nineties, Nasdaq Necromancers and today, Killer BEEs (Delisting Demons, if you’re a pessimist).
Sawdust on the floor, bloody beef and magnums of red: Butchershop is Fight Club for expense-account holders. And it’s all about whose is biggest.
Allow me to break the first rule of Fight Club; and talk about it.
Butchershop is designed to be intimidating. Proprietor Alan Pick doesn’t mince his words about customers’ (bad) habits – judging by the newspaper clippings in the toilets – and he’s happy to announce on signboards just how you’re supposed to enjoy the meat on offer. Well done is grey and chewy. Remember that.
For out-of-towners, Butchershop is about establishing their corporate credentials. There is a steady stream of Potchefstroomers, Port Elizabethans and Polikwanese who come to the big city to pitch their ideas, sell you their story and negotiate the big deal. You need to talk a good fight in this town, is what I say. I’ll pick the venue and you do your damnedest.
Butchershop’s discombobulating reservation system, since revamped, was the first hurdle for the uninitiated: Can’t find a name… are you 47D for four for twelve-thirty? A shrug of the shoulders was usually enough to convince the inductee that it’s just the way things are done here. The system originated in the gold prospecting days; something to do with the way they used to weigh your nuggets. You’re going to fire your secretary for messing this up? Sure, if you really have one.
The Butchershop is not expensive. R90 for a T-bone, and a cheese burger (only served at lunchtime) is R38,50, about the same as at the Spur. It’s more a question of stamina; whether you can last the rounds and take what is constantly thrown at you – onion rings, extra veggies, extra sauce, all R15 and up.
South Africa is one of only six countries in the world with good tap water, says Proudly SAfrican. But the looks from waiters if you ask for anything less than 1,5l sparkling is enough to wither any would-be rainmaker. And if you can get the Butchershop staff to dominate your opponent, the rest of the afternoon will be easy.
Big shots from small towns are used to cheap G&Ts at their country clubs, subsidised out of the groundsmen’s wages. Having the other party choose from Butchershop’s wine selection – Pick claims he is SA’s biggest private wine buyer – is a good way to get them on the back foot.
Picking the Le Riche (R380 for the 2001 Cab Reserve) is a bit obvious – make them pay with the new by-the-glass wine list. Even the “second-cheapest” rule will see them shelling out nearly R70 a glass. And it’s great to see them blink when you suggest that you’ll have that Rémy Martin to wash down the Eland after all. And yes, the Rey Del Mundo Choix Supreme (R170) sounds like a great cigar.
Once you’ve landed a few body punches, it’s time for serious talk: Hmm, I can see how the SMS price-matching system you set up and thoroughly tested among Northwest’s ostrich farmers could be successfully applied on Safex. Please pass the mustard.
Now what were you saying again about how your B2B software fits on one floppy disk but seamlessly integrates with SAP, the monster firm that spends more on R&D in a day than your entire province’s GDP? Ouch, that was a low blow. To make up, I’ll pay for parking.
Hobbling out of there at 4pm (Butchershop lunches always go the distance) I’m reminded of Marlon Brando’s (now a big fat rump in the sky) classic line in On the Waterfront. “Yeah. I coulda been a contender. I coulda been a contender.”

