Thursday, January 26, 2006

Saving Steven Spielberg

YOU MAY BE FORGIVEN if you thought that the theme of this year's American film awards season is gays and lesbians, with some transsexuals thrown in for good measure.

The prime example is Brokeback Mountain (am I the only person who thinks the title is not quite as subtle as the film's producers seem to think?), a love and loss story about two cowboys in the Sixties, which won big at the Golden Globes, the Oscars' precursor. Other favourites were Capote, that tells the life story of Truman Capote, the flamboyant (read camper than a tent town) author of Breakfast at Tiffany's; Transamerica about a pre-op transsexual played by one of the desperate housewives, and film version of The Producers, a gay musical about a gay producer (forgive the tautology).

In most other countries the trend may have barely lifted eyebrows, but Americans clearly have hang-ups about homosexuality - same sex marriage was almost a more divisive issue during its presidential elections than the war in the Middle East.

After years of steering clear of any topic that could bring it even close to controversy or could vaguely be construed as anti-American (recent years' most praised films covered such hot button topics as hobbits, gladiators, samurais, jealous showgirls and mad mathematicians), Hollywood seemed to be back in fighting spirit.

Contrary to the mood of a couple of years ago - booing the one Oscar winner that dares to explore the politics of the day, Michael Moore (Fahrenheit 9/11 and Bowling for Columbine) during his acceptance speech - a raft of contentious political films could be in line for Oscar recognition this year.

Apart from The Constant Gardener (big pharma's exploitation of Africa), Paradise Now (Palestine suicide bombing), Jarhead (the Gulf war), the upcoming Syriana (big oil and corruption) and Good Night and Good Luck (American political scandal), the best example of Hollywood's change of mind is Steven Spielberg's Munich, which opens in SA on Friday. Munich marks a radical departure for the most commercially successful director in film history.

Munich - "Inspired by real events" - deals with Mossad, the Israeli secret service's mission to assassinate those believed to have been behind the terrorist attack at the 1972 Olympic Games in the city. A Palestinian group known as Black September stormed the Olympic village and took 11 Israeli athletes hostage, eventually killing all of them.

That the creator of ET the Extraterrestrial, Jurassic Park and Hook even attempts to address terrorism is reason enough to visit the cinema and to find a tense thriller with Spielberg's characteristic sentimentality largely absent is a welcome surprise. Though it's clear from the outset that Spielberg is busy here with a project potentially much more damaging to his status as filmmaker than the next Indiana Jones adventure, much of the almost three-hour-long movie plays like a conventional spy versus spy action flick.

The hit squad is led by Avner (Eric Bana - previously Hector in Troy and the Hulk), the son of an Israeli war hero who was personally picked by then Prime Minister Golda Meir for the mission. A team is assembled that includes a document forger, a toymaker turned explosives expert and a South African played by the actor picked as the next James Bond, Daniel Craig. Appropriately, he's the getaway driver and Craig's Sefrican accent is about as close to the real thing as you can get without a few howzits and a safari suit.

The period and locales - which include Rome, London, Beirut, Cyprus, Frankfurt and Paris - are meticulously recreated with the help of ample archive footage; 900m people watched the drama unfold live on television - South Africans excepted, of course. The sepia tinting is overused at times, everyone in Seventies Europe seems to be wearing striped brown and orange shirts with wide collars and Munich also suffers from Spielberg's weakness for over-dramatisation: one particularly cringeworthy scene juxtaposes frenzied sex between Avner and his wife with the very graphic violence of the hostage killings.

As the death toll climbs and the number of innocents caught up in the crossfire increases, so do the doubts among Avner's group about the legitimacy of their mission. In between the bombs and the shootings, the assassins discuss the serious moral issues of revenge versus justice (it's an eye for an eye - there are also 11 names on the hit list), freedom fighter versus terrorist, comity versus war.

In one of Avner's conversations, the struggle of the Palestinian Liberation Organisation is even equated to that of the African National Congress. Perhaps not a shocking viewpoint in post-apartheid South Africa, but in the US perhaps even more so than in Israel such sentiments coming from the creator of the touchstone Holocaust film Schindler's List borders on sympathy for terrorists.

Munich was snubbed at the Globes and experienced the expected critical pummelling from hard line circles; perhaps the Hollywood establishment is still not ready to see one of their own brave enough to tackle something more dangerous than dinosaurs.

Wednesday, January 18, 2006

Just shack up

SEE MANY British hipster-cum-NGO types in Jo'burg over the festive season? They shouldn't have been too difficult to spot: they mix Diesel and Camper (expensive gear made to look cheap) and charity shop clothing, are always friendly to roadside vendors of superglue and black bags from inside their rental cars and show an unhealthy interest in skwatta kamps.

I went looking for this breed of foreign tourist after reading a travel article in the London Sunday Observer newspaper, the bleeding heart sister publication of The Guardian. The piece has the usual things to do and places to see, but the writer - one Will Hide - cannot resist dispensing pearls of wisdom about the place where "Africa meets Europe via southern California".

Headlined "Boom Town", Hide's story begins with: "Think you know Johannesburg? Deprivation, racial conflict and urban decay, visible only through a hail of gunshots? Well, it's time to think again."

Let's unpack "Boom Town" and its rather hammy introduction.

Deprivation? If there's one thing Jo'burgers don't allow themselves it is to be deprived. Jo'burg's motto has always been: "You Want It, Take It." It started with the Difaqane, was carried on by the Boers, continued with the Brits and now plunder is open to all. Crime kingpins come from everywhere - Moz, Zim, Israel, India, China and Eastern Europe, though the British criminal element seem to prefer Cape Town (the Health & Racquet Club guys, Mark Thatcher).

Racial conflict? Jo'burg has always been the most mixed city in SA and conflict here has long lost its racial quality - it's always been about money. You only need to see the many white faces on black empowerment company boards or the no-discrimination rule applied in car-jacking and begging at robots.

Urban decay? Sure. But while the CBD was in decline, Jo'burgers built Sandton, Fourways and Midrand while drawing up plans for renewal. Investec's old headquarters turned into a college is just one example of the positive spin-offs of this process (being able to hold rave parties in City Hall was another, but that's another story). At least Jo'burgers never thought building Millennium Domes in derelict areas was a good idea - we keep our white elephants in the veld.

Mr Hide continues: "Part of the trouble is that white Johannesburg - happy, yet paranoid, behind the walls of its shopping malls and BMW dealerships - is only slowly giving the city centre a second chance."

First of all: Don't call me happy. If I wanted to be happy I'd move to Durban; I'm in Jo'burg for the rush, not relaxation. And if Hide stayed long enough, he'd know that only the paranoid thrive here and BMW is the preferred township vehicle. Whites drive Camrys.

As for second chances, there's a basic misunderstanding here, common among old colonials. The success of Newtown and other projects like it is not at all dependent on whether whiteys go back. Newtown needs the white man about as much Hillbrow needs more Congolese and Yeoville needs Nigerians.

"It would be easy just to see the plush, suburban (white) side of Johannesburg, cruising from one shopping mall to the next. Tell people from Houghton you're spending a night in a Soweto B&B and their response is likely to be a look of amusement, astonishment and horror? but visit a township and you'll be enjoying some of Africa's friendliest people, not to mention its best music and cheapest beer."

Ah! Here we have it, then, like an 1820s Cape Colony recruitment poster: "Come to Africa! The natives are friendly and the drink is cheap!" If Mr Hide was really that keen on discovering authentic Jo'burg maybe he'd have noticed that the suburbs haven't been all white for years and Africa's friendliest people can also be enjoyed in the Springbok bar on Ontdekkers after a Currie Cup match, in Coronationville any time over a weekend, Lenasia during Diwali or Mayfair at Eid.

So eager is Mr Hide to let his readers "see the reality of where and how the vast majority of urban South Africans live" that Soweto has somehow become too developed and Alexandra is now "more lively and offers a more authentic experience of urban migration from rural areas".

Does Mr Hide really think that the average migrant would not instantly swap bricolage for "Tuscan villages and gated communities? white SA's neurosis at its most telling" or living 20 to a flat is how "the formerly all-white city centre beats stronger than ever with a new black heart". If Mr Hide returns, I'll organise him an overnight stay in the boot of a car in Diepsloot or locked up in a Ponte apartment with a bottle of glue. I'd love to see him get sentimental about that.

His report ends with a few no-no's for the prospective visitor: "Don't even think about talking about crime over dinner - that's so five years ago. Ditto raving about how fabulous Cape Town is."

I've already broken the first rule and, in fact, I do think Cape Town is fabulous. Next time you're in the country please go there, Mr Hide - I believe Camps Bay has nothing on Langa.