Wednesday, April 06, 2005

Lowbrow lift

REALITY television is an easy target for those who think contemporary culture is on the decline, public discourse has completely dumbed down and the lowest common denominator has finally triumphed in entertainment.

Those who feel superior about reality TV cite the many sleazy dating shows such as Dismissed or Paradise Island, where 20-somethings are forced to spend hours in Jacuzzi’s drinking and chatting up each other or risk getting thrown out of paradise “forever!”, or the numerous extreme extreme makeovers and public humiliations in programmes like The Swan or Who wants a Famous Face?

In May, M-Net will start airing Show me the Mommy, where a bachelor will go on a date with three mothers with eligible daughters. The bachelor then has to decide on the strength of his encounter with mom alone which of the three daughters he’d like to take out.

Show me the Mommy is based on MTV’s Date my Mom and the US version I saw quickly descended into something more like Pimp my Daughter. One mom kept repeating that her Tiffany is a natural blonde, “loves to party” and attends cheerleading classes every week. The guy didn’t pick her.

Not all reality TV is frivolous. In the US a new series called Intervention features the lives of two different addicts (drugs, alcohol, gambling, etc) each week and captures the interventions staged by their families with the help of professional therapists. Exploiting the vulnerable in society or answering a cry for help? I’d sure like to find out.

Britain’s Boss Swap – where two companies exchange chiefs for two weeks – and the parts of The Apprentice that don’t feature Donald Trump’s ego should be part of MBA courses by now. One Boss Swap episode sees a small-town, second-hand car shop owner summarily firing the 2IC and wife of an up-market London property company CEO he’s standing in for after testing her suitability in a couple of isometric tests. It’s funny when it happens on TV, not in HR.

Then there’s Who’s your Daddy?, in which a young female contestant who was adopted must pick her birth father from a group of eight men. If she’s correct, she wins a ton of money; but if she picks one of the fake fathers, he gets the moolla. Unfortunately, the grand reunion finale was cancelled after complaints by the American Adoption Society.

In February, Germans were treated to a show called Sperm Race, by the same company that brought us the daddy of voyeur TV Big Brother, where 12 men competed to see which one has the fastest sperm. The contestants begin by donating sperm in a clinic, where it’s frozen. It’s then sent to the studio, where the sperm will race in front of a live TV audience towards an egg. The most fertile man wins a red Porsche.

These shows certainly play to audiences’ (and contestants’) most puerile and trashy tastes and delight in the misfortunes of others seem to be where much of the appeal with viewers lies. But at least reality TV sometimes serves up insights into how people live their lives today: When was the last time you could say that of a soap series, a crime drama or the seven o’clock news?

Keeping it unreal

BRINGING “reality” and TV together has also resulted in a few new forms, best illustrated by comedy series such as the BBC’s The Office and Arrested Development now being shown on e.tv.

The Office is a fakecumentary about work life that succeeds in being farcical and poignant at the same time, while Arrested Development – filmed documentary style and without a laugh track – about a dysfunctional Los Angeles family breathes life into the ailing post-Friends/Frasier sitcom genre.

Capturing the Friedmans, in limited theatrical release in Johannesburg, is something very different. It’s a disturbing documentary (also described as a non-fiction drama) about a high-profile court case involving paedophilia in New York in the Eighties.

It’s centred on the infighting between the members of the well-to-do Friedman family when the father Arnold – a one-time community “teacher of the year” – is accused of molesting young boys in his computer class.

The director uses present-day interviews with the Friedman family, police investigators, the alleged victims and the defence lawyers. What makes the film particularly harrowing is the family’s hours of 8mm film and home video footage shot in the run-up to Arnold Friedman’s and one of his three sons’ arrest and incarceration. You’re basically watching a family disintegrating around the dinner table and you can’t look away.

But, Capturing the Friedmans also shows that even if you’re watching private conversations of the accused, it’s impossible to know who’s telling the truth.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home