Wednesday, September 28, 2005

Mute penguins preferred over talking extreme deep invader

THE surprise hit movie of the year! Is it Superman? Is it a plane? Is it a bird? It's a bird. This year is shaping up to be a big disappointment for Hollywood, with too many box office flops and renewed worries about the long-term future of the cinema.

The biggest but by no means only bomb so far is Stealth. The film concerns a top-secret fighter plane called EDI and its crew, headlined by Oscar winner Jamie Foxx in a stunningly bad career move, rescuing the world from nuclear disaster. EDI - or Extreme Deep Invader - is a computer-manned prototype aircraft that specialises in extra-precision bombing and talks, says the movie brochure. Maybe because they get this kind of bumf from Donald Rumsfeld et al every other week, audiences stayed away from Stealth.

And the surprise hit movie of the year? A French documentary about penguins trekking across Antarctica to breed. According to at least one critic, March of the Penguins' magnificent exploration of "the tortured life-and-love cycle of the noble emperor penguin soars as one of the most passionate and perceptive expressions of interspecies empathy in the history of the cinema".

Someone should remind this reviewer (from the New York Observer) that people in the south who are more familiar with these animals know that they're flightless, stink and taste bad.

Stealth was made for US$100m. Of course, movie budgets are notorious for being manipulated: if you want to draw audiences for a special effects fest, you pump up the numbers, as many moviegoers equate money with quality or at least spectacle. The producers of Stealth must be rueing that decision, as it only raked in $30m during its short run. A flop is one thing, but to recover from an expensive flop takes years. Just ask Kevin Costner, aka the postman from waterworld. March of the Penguins cost less than $5m to make and has already marched past $70m.

Stealth is the kind of macho, militaristic, patriotic film Hollywood turns out with regularity and ease and, until recently, profitably. March of the Penguins is so packed with family values that the religious right in the US has taken the film under its wing. We should all strive to be more like the emperor penguin is the message for block-booking flocks: they are self-sacrificing, monogamous, not gay and the perfect parents. Anthropomorphism. . . what a lark.

Stealth is tailor-made for the big screen: films about aeroplanes and explosions invariably work better in 16:9 aspect ratio and 10 000 Watt surround sound. The only criticism I've read about March of the Penguins is that people may as well wait until it becomes a National Geographic television special. No wonder many movie moguls now believe that after 50 years, television is finally drawing the curtains on cinema (for the Internet to do the same to traditional TV won't take as long).

So a few waddling penguins show the extreme deep invader where to get off - is this the end of the pro-Pentagon action flick? No. Next year sees action daddy of them all Harrison Ford play a general in a film about the battle for Falluja in Iraq. It took the US decades to make an anti-Vietnam mainstream film, so don't expect anything other than support for the troops from President Ford, hero of Air Force One. And Stealth could still make lots of money as a video game.

Does it mean the triumph of the documentary? No. March of the Penguins is the most successful documentary ever after Fahrenheit 9/11 and, as the recent 3 Continental Film Festival in Johannesburg and Cape Town showed, good documentaries can attract crowds.

After the penguin success, how long before Lassie or Benji returns? Probably not long. The biggest plus factor in March of the Penguins is the fact that, just like Lassie, they don't speak. They're not smart-ass donkeys (Shrek), narcissistic lions (Lion King), timid fish (Finding Nemo) or just plain annoying animals (Madagascar, Shark Tale and many others). All you have is Morgan Freeman's mellifluous grandfather telling a bedtime story voice. Apart from being preposterous and predictable, what critics hated most about Stealth was that it was too loud.

I've only seen snatches of the films (March of the Penguins opens in SA only next year) but even in Eight Legged Freaks and They Nest interspecies empathy and anything with a talking extreme deep invader can't be all bad. So what's with the penguin fascination? Anything for a bit of peace and quiet I guess: with March of the Penguins show business is back in the silent movie era.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home