Wednesday, November 02, 2005

Chick flicks are unpredictable

CHICK FLICK is now a term in the dictionary. How appropriate that it entered the official lexicon at the same time as "bikini wax". Both can be painful, cause shock mingled with awe in men and expose your shortcomings.

Men's aversion to chick flicks is well documented in sitcoms and pop-psychology handbooks, such as Men are from Mars Women are from Venus and the current bestseller He's Just Not That Into You. Would the average man then choose to see In Her Shoes, proclaimed the chick flick of the year, rather than undergo the male version of a bikini wax - the so-called back, sac and crack procedure (not in the dictionary)?

In Her Shoes, from a chick lit novel, is the story of Rose and Maggie, two sisters who are also best friends. Rose is a successful, frumpish, workaholic lawyer who's not so pretty and pretty chubby. Maggie is a lush, promiscuous layabout who's barely numerate and barely literate. They both have low self-esteem, they're both lonely and both wear size 81/2 shoes.

There's also an evil stepmother, a high school reunion, office romances, the discovery of a long lost relative, a wedding, many cute and friendly dogs and shelf upon shelf of shoes in the movie. (Note to self: find out what jimmy choos are, other than apparently the key to a woman's heart.)

Sounds like a classic set-up for a chick flick along the lines of My Best Friends Wedding or Bridget Jones with a bit of Sex and the City and Must Love Dogs thrown in. In short, the female equivalent of a boys' night: a Currie Cup final, followed by Black Hawk Down and Secretaries taking Dicktation VII.

Then you realise that In Her Shoes is by the same director, Curtis Hanson, as LA Confidential, about forced cosmetic surgery for hookers, The Wonder Boys with a doped up professor and his misfit students and 8 Mile, Eminem's ghetto roots, and was produced by Ridley Scott, who also made Gladiator and none other than Black Hawk Down. That's when things go wrong.

Toni Collette plays Rose. Were it not for Hanson's examination of the darker side of being a successful, frumpish, workaholic lawyer who's not so pretty and pretty chubby, Collette could've reprised her lead role in Muriel's Wedding, the Australian comedy classic that shot Collette to Hollywood stardom.

But here you don't know whether you have to giggle when Rose takes a picture of the man she wakes up with as evidence that her life isn't just drudgery and isolation or gasp. That scene early on in the film works, but Rose's frequent humiliations at the hands of her sister, boyfriend and stepmother are mirthless affairs. Before long a gloomy atmosphere settles on the film and the life is drained from the humorous asides and the jokes for their own sake.

Maggie is played by Cameron Diaz. Diaz could have reprised any of her recent roles in In Her Shoes, including the Internet video clip that's now surfaced featuring her soft porn career turn before she shot to Hollywood stardom. (Don't you love these movie clichés? Look out for Nicholas Cage's new film The Weatherman. If the poster blurb is anything to go by, he'll be shot to Hollywood? eh, he'll simply be shot: "Weather is unpredictable. So is life.")

But with Maggie as with Rose the director's proclivity for realism and the conviction that being a lush, promiscuous, layabout who's barely numerate and barely literate is somehow not a viable lifestyle choice becomes a drag on Maggie's natural ebullience.

Guy movies (or should that be dick flicks?) frequently celebrate lyin', stealin', drinkin' and womanisin' but poor Maggie has to go through a transformation process that includes working at a dog grooming parlour, starting a small clothes business and learning poetry - she's thrown in at the deep end with e.e. cummings - from a blind professor in an infirmary. Imagine Deuce Bigalow European Gigolo forced to stutter through: i carry your heart with me (i carry it in my heart) i am never without it (anywhere i go you go, my dear).

The promotional material for In Her Shoes says it's heart-rending and hilarious. "It will make you laugh and cry" is another favourite Hollywood platitude, but the mixed emotions of In Her Shoes borders on the schizophrenic and it's not Diaz's or Collette's fault, who both give strong performances. It's as if the director made a serious film of sibling rivalry, broken families and loneliness and then the Hollywood marketing machine said "Great. Now make it funny."

Still not convinced about the demerits of this chick flick? I forgot to mention that Shirley Maclaine is also in In Her Shoes. Remember she's the star of the grandmother of chick flicks: 1989's Steel Magnolias.

A BSC it is then.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home